Target: Susan M. Howard, District Attorney of Orleans County, New York
Goal: Prosecute to the fullest extent of the law the individual responsible for allegedly hoarding nearly 60 dogs in conditions so dire they required emergency intervention and seizure.
A welfare check at a private residence led to a shocking discovery: nearly 60 dogs allegedly living under conditions so distressing that humane society investigators who responded alongside sheriff’s deputies determined that immediate intervention was necessary to protect the animals’ safety and well-being. All 58 dogs were removed from the property and transported to Lollypop Farm, a local humane society, where they are now receiving care. The scale of this alleged neglect — nearly five dozen living creatures allegedly crammed into a single home — points to a profound and sustained failure of responsibility toward vulnerable animals who had no means to protect or advocate for themselves.
The sheer number of dogs found at this residence raises deeply troubling questions about the conditions they were reportedly forced to endure. When nearly 60 animals are allegedly confined in a single private home, the likelihood of overcrowding, inadequate food and water, insufficient veterinary care, and dangerous levels of waste and disease is severe. Each of these dogs purportedly faced daily suffering with no escape and no voice. The fact that law enforcement and animal welfare officials felt compelled to remove every single animal from the premises underscores just how alarming the situation likely was.
Animals are sentient beings capable of fear, pain, and suffering — and they deserve the protection of the law. When individuals allegedly allow dozens of animals to languish in neglectful and potentially dangerous conditions, they must be held fully accountable. The Orleans County District Attorney’s Office has both the authority and the responsibility to ensure that the person allegedly responsible for this mass neglect faces appropriate criminal charges. Sign this petition to demand that prosecutors pursue this case with the full force of the law.
PETITION LETTER:
Dear District Attorney Howard,
We are writing to urge your office to take swift and decisive action in response to the alleged mass neglect of nearly 60 dogs discovered at a private residence in Lyndonville. According to reports, Orleans County sheriff’s deputies and humane society investigators responded to a welfare check at the property and were so alarmed by what they found that all 58 dogs were immediately removed and placed into the care of Lollypop Farm. The conditions reportedly present were serious enough to warrant full emergency intervention — a chilling indication of the suffering these animals allegedly endured.
We believe that the individual allegedly responsible for housing nearly 60 dogs in conditions that required their mass removal must face the full consequences the law allows. Alleged animal neglect on this scale is not a minor infraction — it represents a prolonged and systematic failure to provide for the basic physical and emotional needs of dozens of living creatures. Each of those 58 dogs reportedly suffered under circumstances that no animal should ever experience.
We respectfully but firmly demand that your office pursue all applicable criminal charges to the fullest extent permitted under New York law. These animals had no ability to seek help on their own — it is now up to the justice system to speak for them. Please ensure that this case is prosecuted with the seriousness it demands and that a clear message is sent that animal neglect of this magnitude will not be tolerated.
Sincerely,
[Your Name Here]
Photo credit: Troy Guo
