
Target: Dr. Stephan Neuheuser, Chief Public Prosecutor, Cologne, Germany
Goal: Review the cruelty sentence concerning cats reportedly confined without adequate food or water, and pursue lawful remedies and justified animal-keeping restrictions.
A promise never to keep pets again is not an enforceable safeguard. Following a cruelty conviction, a woman made that promise in court after allegations that two cats were confined for days without adequate food or water. One cat reportedly died while trying to escape through a tilted window.
The court imposed fifty daily fines of fifteen euros, totaling €750. The defendant admitted the facts and described being overwhelmed. Crucially, the intent necessary for the separate allegation concerning responsibility for the death was not established. The sentence must be assessed against the actual findings, without recasting the case as intentional killing.
The outcome must address proven suffering and future risk. That calls for careful review. Urge prosecutors to examine available appeal grounds promptly and coordinate any justified, enforceable restrictions on keeping animals.
PETITION LETTER:
Dear Dr. Neuheuser,
Please review the judgment in a case involving alleged confining of cats without food or water and consider available animal protection measures. The reported allegations of prolonged confinement and inadequate provisions raise serious welfare concerns. At the same time, the distinction between the cruelty finding and the unproved intent concerning the death must remain explicit.
We ask your office to assess whether the sentence properly reflects the conduct established by the court and whether a lawful appeal is warranted within the applicable deadline. A daily fine depends partly on financial circumstances; its total alone cannot establish that the sentence was inadequate. Consider the judgment, evidence, and available penalties before deciding what further action is justified.
Please also share relevant findings with the competent animal welfare authority so it can assess any continuing risk and the legal basis for restrictions. A personal assurance should be considered alongside objective evidence, rather than replacing a protective assessment. Where warranted, pursue enforceable safeguards through the proper process. We seek a proportionate response respecting the verdict and animal welfare. Please complete that review promptly and pursue any supported remedy capable of strengthening accountability or preventing another animal from suffering.
Sincerely,
[Your Name Here]
Photo credit: Petr Hykš






