Labrador and Beagle Apparently Shot With Arrows and Hidden Deserve Justice

Target: Sean Fagan, Prosecuting Attorney of LaPorte County, Indiana

Goal: Pursue maximum lawful penalties, restitution, psychological evaluation, and lifetime hunting-license revocations for the individuals who allegedly shot two family dogs with arrows and concealed the bodies.

Authorities reportedly recovered evidence showing two beloved pets—a chocolate Labrador retriever and a beagle—were shot with a bow and arrow during a supposed hunting trip. According to a probable cause affidavit, an independent hunter heard the animals whimpering in pain before silence. The dogs were later reportedly found after a damaged GPS collar led investigators to them. These accounts describe disturbing cruelty that turned a routine outing into needless suffering.

Investigators further allege the shooter was elevated in a stand when he fired, suggesting the dogs posed no immediate threat. The father-and-son pair involved allegedly attempted to hide one body and reportedly destroyed the beagle’s GPS collar, actions that appear designed to conceal what happened. Such conduct, if proven, reflects more than a lapse in judgment. It suggests a deliberate disregard for life and the law.

Appropriate accountability can deter future harm. When companion animals are allegedly killed and evidence is purportedly destroyed, communities expect firm prosecution. This petition urges the prosecutor to seek the strongest lawful consequences, including felony-level penalties where applicable, restitution to the guardian, mandated counseling and evaluation, no-contact-with-animals conditions, and lifetime hunting-license revocations to protect public safety and animal welfare.

PETITION LETTER:

Prosecutor Fagan,

Reports and sworn statements describe an incident in which two pet dogs were shot with arrows during a hunting trip, followed by an apparent effort to hide a body and the reported destruction of a GPS collar. Witness accounts include hearing the dogs whimper in pain before all went quiet. These details, if substantiated in court, depict serious and senseless cruelty.

The suggestion that the shooter was positioned on an elevated stand when firing, as reported, undermines any claim of imminent danger. The alleged concealment and tampering reinforce the need for meaningful accountability. Cases like this reverberate through the community and the lawful hunting tradition, which rejects needless suffering and any attempt to obstruct investigations.

We respectfully urge your office to pursue the maximum lawful penalties upon conviction, including restitution, mandated psychological evaluation and counseling, no-contact-with-animals provisions, and lifetime hunting-license revocations. Robust prosecution can help ensure this alleged brutality is met with appropriate consequences and can deter future offenses.

Sincerely,

[Your Name Here]

Photo Credit: Blaine Hansel