Target: Katherine Fernandez Rundle, State Attorney, Eleventh Judicial Circuit, Florida
Goal: Pursue supported cruelty charges involving a dog allegedly left emaciated on a filthy balcony and seek appropriate penalties if neglect is proven.
A dog allegedly lay on an apartment balcony amid accumulated waste, its body visibly emaciated. Neighbors’ recordings helped draw attention to the animal, and authorities intervened. The alleged condition of a pet confined above the street raises serious questions about food, care, and daily supervision.
Kevin Benjamin was charged with animal cruelty after the rescue. Reporting says he was released on bond, rather than remaining continuously in custody. The charge must be tested through medical findings and evidence of responsibility. Emaciation warrants investigation, but its cause and the caretaker’s conduct must be established rather than assumed.
Prosecutors should examine the alleged deprivation alongside any relevant medical history or explanation. Demand diligent pursuit of supported charges, continuing protective care, and proportionate punishment if the evidence proves criminal neglect.
PETITION LETTER:
Dear State Attorney Fernandez Rundle,
Please ensure that the case against Kevin Benjamin, involving a dog allegedly left suffering on a balcony, receives a thorough review. The reports of extreme thinness and accumulated waste are deeply concerning. We ask that veterinary findings explain the animal’s health, likely causes of its condition, and treatment needs.
Preserve the neighbors’ original recordings, responding officers’ observations, and rescue documentation. Establish who was responsible for feeding, water, sanitation, and medical decisions during the relevant period. Review available treatment records and the accused person’s explanation fairly. Coordinate with Animal Services on appropriate care and lawful custody arrangements while the criminal case proceeds.
Where the evidence supports prosecution, pursue charges reflecting the established conduct and seek proportionate penalties upon conviction. Consider any legally available animal-possession restrictions justified by proven neglect and the risk of recurrence. Please keep the animal’s recovery and long-term safety in view alongside the court process. We ask for an outcome grounded in evidence, meaningful accountability for any proven cruelty, and a secure future for the rescued dog.
Sincerely,
[Your Name Here]
Photo credit: Loco Steve
