By Nick Engelfried
On Spain’s Canary Islands, an international seafood company wants to build the world’s first large industrial octopus farm, raising and slaughtering animals widely considered to be the world’s most intelligent invertebrates. Octopuses, which are solitary creatures in the wild, would be kept in tanks with dozens grouped together in close quarters, conditions that could lead to aggression and cannibalism. When the time comes for the animals to be killed and sold as seafood, they would be placed in a slurry bath of ice flakes and cold water whose temperature would be gradually lowered below freezing, subjecting the animals to slow and potentially agonizing deaths.

Animal rights organizations have called the proposed treatment of farmed octopuses cruel, while scientists have raised concerns about the capacity of these intelligent animals for suffering. There have even been mass protests against octopus farming as public backlash mounts over the idea of raising another animal under inhumane conditions in order to produce what is largely a luxury seafood item.

Despite being radically different from humans and other mammals, octopuses are renowned for possessing an intelligence that at times seem eerily like our own. They learn quickly, use tools, and even construct what appear to be decorative “gardens” out of rocks. There is strong evidence to suggest octopuses experience pain, pleasure, and perhaps even affection. They seem to exhibit curiosity and playfulness–hallmarks of intelligence more commonly associated with certain mammals and birds. All of this has added to the sense of alarm many people feel at the prospect of these creatures being raised for food under what are essentially factory farm-like conditions.

Humans have been eating octopuses for thousands of years, with coastal Indigenous peoples in different parts of the world hunting them alongside other types of wild seafood. Today, octopuses are still widely eaten in places like Japan, Mexico, and Europe’s Mediterranean region. However, while a long tradition of consuming wild-caught octopuses exists in many cultures, up to now no one has farmed them for food on a large scale–partly because the eight-legged animals are notoriously difficult to raise in captivity.

Newly born octopuses–known and larvae–only eat live food and have very specific environmental requirements. Yet, as our understanding of octopus lifecycles has increased, raising them in captivity has become increasingly feasible. Now, the Spanish seafood giant Nueva Pescanova is awaiting government permission to build the world’s first major octopus farm on the Canary Islands. The facility could eventually slaughter a million animals per year to produce 3,000 tons of octopus meat for sale on the international market.

“In the face of overwhelming scientific evidence, ethical concerns, and global opposition, creating the world’s first [major] octopus farm is a perilous path we must not tread,” read a recent statement from Keri Tietge, Octopus Project Consultant for the group Eurogroup for Animals. “Octopuses, solitary in nature, and with extremely complex behaviors, simply do not suit intensive farming conditions.”

No company has yet raised captive octopuses on the scale Nueva Pescanova is proposing. However, there has been at least one apparent attempt at octopus farming for profit in the United States–while in other parts of the world, like Japan, the idea has attracted substantial attention. This means if Nueva Pescanova’s project goes forward, it could provide a template for similar projects in other parts of the world.

In January of last year, the first and so far only U.S. octopus farm shut down in Hawaii. Before closing its doors for good, the Kanaloa Octopus Farm became mired in allegations of malpractice and misleading the public. Its owner, Jacob Conroy, claimed to be operating a research facility that contributed to conservation efforts. However, investigators affiliated with animal rights groups assert that there is scant evidence that the farm was engaged in meaningful scientific research. What it did do was offer the tourists the chance to interact with captive octopuses, charging $50 per visitor. While the farm claimed not to sell octopuses for consumption, animal rights groups allege that Conroy’s statements show the intent from the beginning was to eventually raise octopuses for high-end seafood.

Other accusations against Kanaloa include that it captured wild octopuses it claimed were “rescued” from fishing vessels, and that octopuses died after escaping from poorly-secured tanks. These reported scandals contributed to Kanaloa shutting down, but the controversies surrounding the facility suggest the kinds of problems that could emerge at other octopus farming projects in the future. It seems an inauspicious start to what some seafood companies see as a burgeoning new global industry.

Supporters of octopus farming say the practice could alleviate pressure on wild populations, which have suffered in recent years because of increased demand for their meat. However, there is little concrete evidence to suggest industrial-scale breeding of other marine animals has benefitted wild members of the species. In fact, farming may even have a negative effect by helping to establish a permanent market for the species in question–which in turn creates a greater incentive to hunt wild individuals.

In past centuries, octopuses in many parts of the world were hunted as part of subsistence hunter-gatherer cultures that harvested local seafood in a sustainable manner. Today, however, octopus is more often used as an ingredient in high-end seafood, with demand for octopus meat increasing as incomes have risen in parts of the world where it is popular. This raises the ethical question of whether it makes sense to develop a new industry to breed an intelligent animal in cramped, unnatural conditions in order to serve demand for a luxury product?

Opposition to octopus farming is already having an effect in some parts of the world. Some European governments have expressed skepticism about the practice. In the United States, the lower house of the Washington State legislature recently passed a bill that would preemptively ban octopus farming in the state. Meanwhile, as of now, the Nueva Pescanova’s proposed octopus farm in the Canary Islands has yet to receive all the government permits it needs before construction can begin. This means animal lovers still have a chance to stop the octopus farming industry before it takes off.

How policymakers and the public deal with the question of whether to allow this controversial industry to move forward over the next few years may determine whether octopus farming takes root and spreads around the world. It will also decide whether millions of some of the ocean’s most intelligent animals are subjected to lives of potential abuse and confinement–only to eventually suffer slow deaths by freezing.

Photo credit: MathieuTTL

Wait, there’s one more step:

Over 1,483,780 Animal Shelter Meals Donated So Far –

Upgrade to a Premium Membership to get a free Animals Are Earth’s Greatest Treasure shirt, feed shelter animals with the Educational Series and Meal Wheel, sign 100’s of petitions with one-click, remove ads, and promote your favorite petitions to millions!

7 day money-back guarantee for new members. Zero risk.

Premium Membership comes with the following perks:

• Get a free Animals Are Earth’s Greatest Treasure shirt.
• Feed shelter animals by spinning the Meal Wheel.
• Sign 100’s of petitions with one-click.
• Feed shelter animals with the Educational Series quizzes.
• Remove ads and vote on which petitions are displayed to millions of people.

Our Guarantee:

Cancel your subscription for any reason within 7 days and we’ll refund 100% of your money, as long as you’re a first time member.

Frequently Asked Questions:

How are the animal shelter meals donated?

We donate shelter meals through Rescue Bank because they research all shelters, maintain equitable distribution, and track the meals from their facilities all the way to the rescue groups. This ensures that the donation will be utilized in the most efficient and impacting way.

Why don’t we just donate meals without providing any perks like the Meal Wheel?

We’ve been at this since 2008 and have learned that to really make a difference, we need to get people excited and engaged. Our mission is a serious one, but our methods are playful and educational. We’re serious about doing good, but also want to make it fun.

Who are we?

We are a family of sites that works to protect animals, the environment, and more. Our sites include AnimalPetitions.org and ForceChange.com. We’ve been at this for over a decade and are dedicated to protecting and defending animals and the environment. If we can have some fun and improve the world, then we’re accomplishing our goal!

Try Premium!

We’ve Been Doing This for Over a Decade and Others Have Taken Notice:

7 Day Guarantee!

Testimonials:

“Thank you SO much for the premium feature of being able to sign multiple petitions with one click. Many of us go for hours at a time signing each and every petition and crying as we read them. I have often wished for a way to sign my name on every petition because I passionately support them and they all need our voice. This is the best thing – thank you very much!” -Karilyn K., Premium Member

“This is just the most amazing wonderful service that makes me so happy! To be able to feed shelter pets is just the greatest feeling. Thanks again for this, and for all you do for the most innocent and helpless among us, the animals. I’m lovestruck.” Sandra Z., Premium Member

“I love the upgrade option and I am so glad I did it.....it enables me to stand with you and many others to fight for the justice these precious souls deserve! We are their voice!!!! And....I adore helping to feed them as well! The spin the wheel game is fun....and I like doing it everyday to help! Keep up the wonderful work....and I know....every click makes a difference!” Dorothy B., Premium Member

“I am so excited to become a Premium Member and to have one-click signing, as I was spending countless hours signing petitions...not that I mind doing it, but my goodness, there sure are a lot of them. I always hope that my signature somehow helps, because these people that abuse/torture animals, need to be put away. As you can tell, that is my passion, I have such a heart for animals, and I want to be their voice.” Darlene R., Premium Member

“Thank you so much! I love being a premium member and spinning that wheel every day, especially when I land on 4 or, best of all, 5 meals. Thank you for all you do, we are all so grateful for you.” Sandy T., Premium Member

“With deepest Aloha, You have no idea how grateful I am for you!” Jan L., Premium Member

“Thank you for the Premium Membership option. I really appreciate that I can sign multiple petitions with one click. It's great! Thank you for the work you do.” Ashley H., Premium Member

“I absolutely love the Educational Series!” Yvonne L., Premium Member

"I am a premium member and religiously sign every petition. THANK YOU for this platform. I also vote for the petition nearest my heart, sometimes voting globally, sometimes I am caught by an individual animal's plight. What gives me great pleasure is noting that almost always, the percentages have no more than a 6-7% spread. It means that, overall, everyone cares about all of the petitions ALMOST EQUALLY! LOL, I also spin that wheel, and when I get 4 or 5 meals, I dance around the room! I have long maintained that what someone does to a helpless animal, they will do to a weaker human if they think that they can get away with it. Those who abuse, no matter how many legs their victims have, should be punished to the fullest extent of the law." Rebecca E., Premium Member

"I LOVE LOVE LOVE my Premium Membership! Everything and anything I can do to help animals and contribute to justice in the world makes me very happy!" Jan L., Premium Member

"Thank you, I love what you do. My friends and I love the membership because we can sign so many more petitions that we may never had heard of. Keep up the good work." Virginia G., Premium Member

---

Still have questions? Email us: organize@forcechange.com

Nick Engelfried Writes About Animals, the Environment, and Conservation for the ForceChange network