Tell State to Strengthen Animal Cruelty Penalties


Target: Ohio Lawmakers

Goal: Strengthen animal cruelty charges

In Ohio, no matter whether the animal cruelty charge is hanging an animal, torturing an animal, or struggling to feed an animal after a lost job, the penalty is the same: a misdemeanor. The penalties need to be changed based on the severity of the crime, and animal cruelty needs to be made a felony.

Ohio’s lax laws on animal cruelty place the state 34th in the Animal Legal Defense Fund 2012 U.S. Animal Protection Laws Rankings. It took years and a tremendous outpouring of support before Nitro’s Law finally passed in Ohio to make animal cruelty a felony for kennel owners, operators and employees. Nitro’s Law protects animals wherever a kennel license is in effect with the exception of large breeding facility, most likely a puppy mill. That means any facility that holds a commercial kennel license, whether it be a boarding, training, breeder, rescue facility. But animal cruelty is still not a felony for most people.

For example, Phillip McClay brutally killed a stray cat. The Ohio man beat the cat, broke its neck, and as if that wasn’t enough, he then hanged then shot the cat. McClay was charged with a second-degree misdemeanor. Cases like these show that animal cruelty should be made a felony.

Currently, under Ohio law, second-degree misdemeanor penalty is up to ninety days in jail or a $750 fine. If the laws were to change animal abuse to a fifth-degree felony, the minimum penalty would be six months in jail. For animal abusers like Phillip McClay, six months in jail is not enough to cover his crimes, and the current penalty of up to ninety days in jail or $750 is a mere pittance. Tell Ohio to rethink their current animal abuse penalties and make animal abuse a felony in all cases.


Dear Ohio lawmakers,

The current penalty for most people on a charge of animal abuse is a misdemeanor unless the people charged are a commercial facility with a kennel license. This is not a harsh enough penalty. People do heinous things to animals, and getting off with such little penalty is ridiculous.

Please do right by the animals and increase the penalty for animal cruelty. Making it a felony would at least get most animal abusers off the streets and protect other helpless animals from crossing paths with these monsters.


[Your Name Here]

Photo credit: Nikita Kravchuk via Flickr

Sign the Petition

  • Only your name will be displayed. By signing, you accept our terms and may receive updates on this and related causes.
FacebookCare2 NewsTwitterEmailShare


  1. Pourquoi louer des chiens ?!! A Miami entre autre
    Seule les voitures et les maisons ce louent !

    Pauvres animaux constament bouleverse et sans compter les risques….

  2. renee jeanine ragno says:

    How you treat a child, an animal, innocent, helpless, defenseless w/o a voice shows the character of a country, its people and a person. Aren’t we alledgely the more intelligent, humane?! Its time to put an end to cruelty to animals to uphold the fundamentals, ethics, morals, humanity, honor. Maybe that explains why people are treating each other so horribly and life seems to have no value. No empathy.

  3. The majority of serial killers, rapists, and other heinous crimes ALL start off with the abuse of animals. It starts off with abuse that turns into torture. These sick people move on to humans and with each crime they do, they get more and more brave. So many of our horrific crimes could have been intercepted if we, as a society and law makers, would have intervened when they first started their sick and twisted torture of animals.

    • Daniela Bress says:

      Oh, you’re so right; just remember Eric Newman alias Luca Magnotta. I really wonder why the majority of this stupid human being still refuse to realize that the victim’s number of legs is totally unimportant regarding the danger to society that a typical tormentor represents!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Facebook Comments


2168 Signatures

  • Alice Rim
  • Jenna Miles
  • Loretta Pesteanu
  • James Thrailkill
  • joan walker
  • sheila childs
  • Chris Verhaegen
  • Mal Gaff
  • Erin Borozny
  • Holly Hall
1 of 217123...217
Skip to toolbar