Punish Amish Man Who Allegedly Beat Fallen Horse

Target: Ephrata, PA Police Chief William Harvey

Goal: Punish the Amish man who reportedly beat a horse until it collapsed and died to the fullest extent of the law.

An Amish man allegedly overburdened his horse by having it carry nearly a ton of watermelon and two grown men. When it seemed to have trouble carrying such a large load, the man walked along side the horse and struck it, punching and kicking the animal until it collapsed on the freeway, after which he then beat it some more. A woman who was driving by happened to see the incident and called the police, but when police and firefighters arrived, they failed in trying to save the horse’s life and the animal died right there on the freeway.

When police and firefighters arrived at the scene, they tried to revive the horse and cool it down, using over 1,000 gallons of water in an effort to re-hydrate the horse and get it back to stable condition. However, due to the extremely burdensome conditions it was placed under and the injuries sustained from being beaten by the Amish man, the horse was not able to recover and died shortly after collapsing. When abuse is so extreme that the animal can’t even recover from the injuries sustained, it’s time to implement federal animal abuse charges.

Police told the woman that the Amish are governed under different law and it would be difficult to prosecute the animal abuser. Demand that the police chief prosecute the Amish man under felony animal abuse charges to set an example that abuse is abuse, no matter who commits it.


Dear Chief Williams,

One of your officers reportedly told the woman who called the police on an Amish man for beating an exhausted horse that the Amish were not governable under Pennsylvania law and that they would be difficult to prosecute. This obviously was not the case as you were able to arrest the man under animal cruelty charges. However, these charges do not go far enough. In order to set an example for the Amish, and for animal abusers everywhere, it is only right that you charge this man with felony animal abuse.

Burdening a horse to the point of exhaustion and then beating it until collapses when it doesn’t carry the burdensome load is nothing short of felony animal abuse. The conditions were so bad that firefighters couldn’t revive the horse with over 1,000 gallons of water. Nothing about this crime is worth two small animal cruelty charges.

This man should be punished to the fullest extent of the law, regardless of his religious affiliation. It’s time the Ephrata Police Department send a message to Amish citizens across the state that they are punishable under the same laws as the rest of us, no matter their religious beliefs.


[Your Name Here]

Photo credit: Tawn Crowther

Sign the Petition

  • Upgrade to sign 100's of petitions with one-click and feed shelter animals.
  • Only your name will be displayed. By signing, you accept our terms and may receive updates on this and related causes.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
FacebookCare2 NewsTwitterEmailShare



  2. Cynthia Howell says:


  3. Angela Rabon says:

    I don’t care if he is Amish or what he is!! He lives in America and is governed by the state of Pennsylvania’s Animal Cruelty Laws…Period!! Those officers should have done their job!! That is ridiculous!!!!

  4. I thought the amish were supposed to be gentle people, well this disgusting evil moron is not & he has to be punished & prosecuted, I don’t care if they have a different law animal cruelty should not be allowed by any law, please charge him & put him in prison, he deservers to be punished the Horse deserves him to be punished.

  5. amish people live in this country should follow the same LAWS as the rest of us !!! thats UNFAIRNESS that they go by one set of laws and we go by another !!!! THESE OLD OUTDATED LAWS SHOULD BE UPDATED !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  6. Inadequate laws must change, now! Justice for the poor horse, now!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Facebook Comments


2231 Signatures

  • Clarence Cote
  • Lucilla Bellucci
  • Kathleen Kubinak
  • Guna S
  • Mr. & Mrs. Terry Cadwallader
  • Terri Copps
  • Christine Witcher
  • trish gallardo
  • Dawn Barber
1 of 223123...223
Skip to toolbar