Demand Jail Time for Alleged Repeat Puppy Mill Operator

Target: Keith M. Kaneshiro, Prosecuting Attorney for the City and County of Honolulu

Goal: Punish dog breeder accused of neglecting over 30 dogs and dumping dead and sick dogs in the trash.

Two dogs, one alive and one dead, were recently found in a Kahaluu, Honolulu garbage can. Reports say that the dead dog had been shot to death and the one left alive was anemic and severely emaciated. After obtaining a warrant to search the home where the garbage can was left out for collection, authorities uncovered a puppy mill.

According to animal control, over 30 small dogs were found in two separate rooms of the house. The dogs were left without food or water, and were forced to live in their own filth, said one rescuer. The smell was so horrendous that the officer reported her eyes burning from the ammonia fumes coming off of the dog waste.

The owner of the home, James Montgomery, is a part-time dog breeder who has previously been involved in similar cruelty cases. In 2005, police discovered 65 neglected dogs and one dead dog in his home. After pleading guilty to 55 counts of animal cruelty, a judge ordered the man’s animals returned to him.

Lax punishments such as these are obviously not helping to save animals from abuse or convince animal abusers to change their ways. Had this man been properly punished for his crimes in the past, the 33 dogs recently found could have potentially been saved from extensive suffering. In order to ensure this man does not re-offend, it is imperative that he is dealt with harshly this time around. Sign the petition below to urge the prosecutor to seek the maximum possible penalty, which includes jail time and a ban on owning animals in the future.


Dear Mr. Kaneshiro,

Over 30 dogs were recently found without food or water and living in shocking filth. The dogs were discovered after authorities received a report of two dogs thrown in the homeowner’s garbage can. The homeowner, James Montgomery, has prior animal abuse convictions but was previously let off the hook without so much as a ban on owning animals in the future.

Clearly, treating animal cruelty crimes as unimportant only serves to perpetuate animal abuse. In order to ensure that this man does not re-offend, he must be punished to the fullest extent of the law. We, the undersigned, ask that you seek jail time for this man as well as a lifetime ban on animal ownership.


[Your Name Here]

Photo credit: Polikarpus

Sign the Petition

  • Upgrade to sign 100's of petitions with one-click and feed shelter animals.
  • Only your name will be displayed. By signing, you accept our terms and may receive updates on this and related causes.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
FacebookCare2 NewsTwitterEmailShare


  1. Orna Zagiel says:

    But the Judge in jail also – what stupid judge gives back the dogs to this non-humane person…..

  2. WTF is this mentally deranged lunatic idiot still a “judge”??!?
    This is so disturbing. The judge obviously is a moronic idiot with no compassion for animals. This man dosent deserve to be a Judge. To GIVE THE ABUSED ANIMALS, TO THE ABUSER HIMSELF, AFTER HE PLED GUILTY TO 55 COUNTS OF ANIMAL CRUELTY!! That’s so disturbing that judges like this even exist. THIS judge needs to have his licence revoked. Unbelievable.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Facebook Comments


887 Signatures

  • Melody Montminy
  • Izumi Ogawa-Schulz
  • patricia calebrese
  • Betty Jones
  • Ken Kurtz
  • Linda Cypert
  • Sally Dickens
  • Diane and Jerry Tabbott
1 of 89123...89
Skip to toolbar