Tell The New York Times That No One Is Illegal

Target: Jill Abramson, editor of The New York Times 

Goal: Allow Times journalists to refer to immigrants as “undocumented” rather than “illegal”

Language has power–especially when wielded by one of the foremost news publications in the country. That’s why immigration activists were shocked to discover that The New York Times doesn’t just encourage its writers to use the phrase “illegal immigrant” in reference to those living in the United States without visas. Its style guide actually mandates the term, prohibiting journalists from using any alternative words like “undocumented” or “unauthorized” in reference to immigrants.

Rhetoric surrounding immigration has grown harsher over the past decade, as even news outlets sworn to neutrality brandish terms like “illegal immigrant” and “illegal alien” with increasing frequency. Using the word “illegal” to refer to people themselves rather than their activity cements the image of undocumented immigrants as criminals dodging the justice system in order to take advantage of American prosperity and “steal” jobs from local workers.

The New York Times‘s style guide includes the following disconcerting entry on “illegal immigrant”: ¬†“illegal immigrant is the preferred term, rather than the sinister-sounding illegal alien. Do not use the euphemism undocumented.”

Dubbing “undocumented” as a euphemism when it is in fact the preferred term that immigrants use to describe their status removes power from those most directly affected by the Times‘s language. By barring journalists from using undocumented immigrants’ preferred identity language, the Times is inflicting rhetorical violence upon those who are already at risk of violence, abuse and deportation.

Tell The New York Times to stop insisting upon the derogatory term “illegal immigrant” and permit journalists to describe immigrants as “undocumented.”

PETITION LETTER

Dear Jill Abramson,

As the editor of one of the most prestigious publications in the world, it is your responsibility to ensure The New York Times does not publish language that amounts to rhetorical violence against vulnerable groups. By insisting that journalists use the term “illegal immigrant” to refer to those living in the United States without documentation, you are promoting the idea that these immigrants are inherently criminals–that their very identity is illegal.

Undocumented immigrants already face violence and harassment across the country, much of it from law enforcement officials overstepping their duties to inflict fear upon Latino communities. I hope they don’t have to additionally face rhetorical violence from your publication for much longer. Amend your style guide to allow the use of words like “undocumented” or “unauthorized” to refer to immigrants living in the United States.

Sincerely,

[Your Name Here]

 

Sign the Petition

  • Your email will not be published. By signing you accept the ForceChange terms of service and may receive updates on this and related petitions.

Facebook Comments

comments

5 Comments

  1. Immigrants come here to escape the most unbearable conditions in their countries, to improve their lives and to contribute to our country.

  2. The term “illegal” is derogatory and incites racism. No one on this planet is illegal. We all have a right to exist and should be welcome in a country that claims to be a refuge for people to come to and escape dangerous or impoverished countries.

  3. Grow some wont you! You’re the reason people are afraid to speak their minds. I came to this country in 69. LEGALLY. I am proud of that. Those who enter regardless of the conditions at home ILLEGALLY should be called just that! CALL A DUCK A DUCK!

    • I wasn’t finished yet. Call a duck a duck I said. To go on. This society has become a society of VICTIMS. Let an American cross the border illegally. Shot on sight! Where are their rights? The border patrol officer killed on duty because he was not ALLOWED to carry a firearm. Why? to PROTECT THE ILLEGAL ALIENS CROSSING THE BORDER! So they can sell their drugs and hoar out their women and shoot and kill OUR OFFICERS while they are protecting us! I’m sick of it!

      • Everyone wants to go to a country (here) Where the poor people are fat, The term illegal only bothers you until these people are in YOUR living room eating out of YOUR fridge! Then What? Because their support has to come from somewhere!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Signatures

  • alper arslan
  • pletcherdahXI
  • carpinteyroursEW
  • pletchertlwZB
  • pletcherdffZB
  • pletcherzgcAI
  • carpinteyrorgrEW
  • pletchermilEW
1 of 6123...6